When upgrading or replacing your garage door, you might come across the terms “shiplap” and “tongue and groove.” While these styles are often discussed in woodwork and interior design, they also play a role in garage doors. Understanding their differences will help you make the best decision for your home. Let’s break it down.
What Are Shiplap and Tongue and Groove in Garage Doors?
Both shiplap and tongue and groove refer to the way the panels of your garage door fit together. They determine how well the door seals against the elements and how it looks once installed.
- Shiplap Panels: These have a slight overlap, allowing panels to fit snugly but with a small gap for natural expansion and contraction. This makes them a great choice for a classic and rustic appearance while still providing a sturdy structure.
Tongue and Groove Panels: These interlock tightly, creating a strong seal that blocks out air, moisture, and dirt more effectively. This method of construction provides a more seamless look and enhances insulation by reducing heat loss.
Which One is Better for a Garage Door?
If you’re looking for performance, tongue and groove is the winner. Because the panels interlock, they create a better barrier against weather, reducing drafts and improving insulation. This can be especially useful if you have an attached garage or want to maintain a more controlled temperature inside.
Shiplap, while still effective, has small gaps that can allow slight airflow. If your garage isn’t climate-controlled or insulation isn’t a priority, shiplap can still be a great choice for its classic, clean look.
Cost Comparison: Shiplap vs. Tongue and Groove Garage Doors
Many homeowners assume one style is significantly more expensive than the other. However, for the same door material and design type, the cost is usually the same. The price of your garage door will depend more on material, insulation, and style rather than whether it’s shiplap or tongue and groove.
Factors That Affect Cost
Material Choice – Whether you choose wood, steel, aluminum, or composite, the material will be the biggest cost factor.
Insulation – Insulated doors will cost more than non-insulated ones, but they save money on energy bills in the long run.
Design Customization – Custom finishes, colors, and window additions can increase the final price.
Installation Fees – Hiring professionals to install your garage door ensures proper function and longevity but will add to the overall cost.
Other Important Considerations
1. Weather Resistance & Insulation
If you live in an area with extreme temperatures, tongue and groove will provide better insulation. Since the panels fit more securely, they reduce heat transfer and help keep your garage comfortable. This can be particularly beneficial for attached garages, as it minimizes heat loss from your home.
Shiplap panels, while durable, may allow slight air leakage due to the overlapping design. If you frequently experience heavy storms, high winds, or fluctuating temperatures, the tighter seal of tongue and groove panels could offer better protection and energy efficiency.
2. Safety & Pinch-Proof Options
Some garage doors come with pinch-proof designs, especially for homes with children. This feature prevents fingers from getting caught between panels as the door opens and closes. While both shiplap and tongue and groove doors can offer pinch-resistant technology, the interlocking design of tongue and groove generally makes it safer.
Additionally, pinch-proof designs improve durability by preventing excess wear and tear on the joints of the panels, which can extend the lifespan of your garage door.
3. Panel Interchangeability
One common mistake homeowners make is thinking they can mix and match garage door panels. You can’t interchange shiplap and tongue and groove panels—each type is designed to fit in a specific way. Additionally, there are multiple panel options within each style, meaning that even within the same type, not all panels are compatible.
Because of this, if you’re replacing a section of your garage door, it’s crucial to use the same panel style as the rest of the door. Using mismatched panels can compromise the door’s structural integrity and visual appeal. Or it won’t fit together at all.
4. Installation Process
No matter which style you choose, the installation process remains the same. There’s no difference in difficulty or speed between installing a shiplap garage door and a tongue and groove one. Both require professional installation to ensure proper alignment, security, and long-term performance.
Garage doors need to be properly balanced and fitted to function correctly. Regardless of whether you choose shiplap or tongue and groove, an experienced technician will be able to install your door efficiently and safely.
5. Aesthetic Differences
Both shiplap and tongue and groove doors offer distinct aesthetic benefits.
Shiplap Garage Doors – Perfect for a traditional or farmhouse-style home, giving off a rustic and cozy vibe.
Tongue and Groove Garage Doors – Provide a smooth, polished finish that works well with modern and contemporary homes.
Depending on your home’s design, either choice can elevate curb appeal, increasing the overall value of your property.
What is the new trend instead of shiplap?
While shiplap remains popular, newer trends in garage door and home design are shifting towards board and batten, smooth paneling, and reclaimed wood finishes. These options provide a more modern and contemporary look while still offering durability and style. Homeowners looking for a sleek, minimalistic approach often prefer smooth panel doors, while board and batten styles give a more structured, dimensional effect.
Why not to use shiplap?
Shiplap is a great design choice, but it may not be the best option for everyone. Some reasons why homeowners might choose to avoid shiplap for garage doors include:
Less effective sealing – Shiplap panels overlap rather than interlock, which can allow slight air and moisture infiltration.
Potential for warping – In humid or extreme weather conditions, the small gaps in shiplap can lead to expansion and contraction issues.
Maintenance concerns – Dirt and debris can get trapped in the gaps between panels, requiring more frequent cleaning.
Is shiplap or tongue and groove more expensive?
Generally, the cost of shiplap and tongue and groove garage doors is about the same when using the same material and design type. The price will be influenced more by factors like:
Material choice (wood, composite, metal, etc.)
Insulation level
Customization options (color, finish, hardware)
Installation costs
If you are choosing between the two, price is unlikely to be the deciding factor.
What is better, shiplap or tongue and groove?
The best choice depends on your needs and priorities:
For better insulation and weather resistance: Tongue and groove is the superior choice because the panels interlock tightly, preventing drafts and heat loss.
For a classic or rustic aesthetic: Shiplap offers a traditional farmhouse or cottage-style appearance that many homeowners love.
For durability and minimal maintenance: Tongue and groove panels are less likely to allow dirt buildup and provide a sturdier, long-lasting fit.
Which One Should You Choose?
If insulation, weather resistance, and a tighter seal are your priorities, tongue and groove is the better option. However, if you love the look of shiplap and don’t need the extra seal, it’s still a solid choice. Either way, the cost remains similar, so your decision should be based on function and aesthetics rather than price. Looking for a high-quality garage door with the perfect design for your home? Call us at (425) 454-3250 or browse our selection to find the best fit for your garage. Whether you choose shiplap or tongue and groove, we’ll ensure a smooth installation and lasting performance!
